Monday, November 02, 2009
J Street and strained Turkey-Israel relationship
Friday, October 30, 2009
J Street comes alive on Washington, DC map
HURRIYET DAILY NEWS
The Israel-Palestine peace process – a top foreign-policy objective of the Obama administration – faces continued challenges after months of intense diplomatic talks engineered by George Mitchell, the U.S. envoy for the Middle East. These negotiations have produced a mere handshake between U.S. President Barack Obama, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, without being able to produce any framework for an ongoing peace process.
Obama's tough rhetoric against Netanyahu backfired, said Ami Ayalon, the former head of the Shin Bet, Israel's secret service, and former commander in chief of the navy after a panel discussion at the J Street conference in Washington, D.C. The initial stalemate was presented by Netanyahu as a victory, which was in reality a mere defense of the status quo, he added. Ayalon also stated that after this first round of diplomacy, Obama started to be viewed as a collaborator with the current Israeli administration, which created some questions in the Arab world regarding the degree to which he can uphold his strong stance against Israeli demands.
Under these circumstances, I asked Jeremy Ben-Ami, the executive director of the J Street movement, to describe his organization to me. "[J Street] is the political voice of American Jews and other Americans who believe that it is in our best interests and as well as that of Israel to end the conflict with the Palestinians and to have a two-state solution and a comprehensive peace process in the Middle East."
J Street, with a history a mere 18 months in the making, attracted thousands of supporters, the support of hundreds of the members of Congress, high-profile attendees and the Obama administration's unequivocal backing last week. The Obama administration has shown its support by sending the National Security Adviser, Ret. General James L. Jones, to represent the President and to speak at the conference. Gen. Jones concluded that "this U.S. administration will participate in J Street's other activities in the future." On the other hand, while J Street hosted many members of Congress, Republicans and Democrats alike, the one person who shied away from the conference was Israel's ambassador to Washington, D.C., Michael Oren. According to the statement that was released by the Israeli embassy, there were "concerns over certain policies of the organization that may impair the interests of Israel."
One would rightly ask why is it that this new movement attracted so much attention and sparked a range of discussion in America and across the globe, while Israel already has a mighty lobby, centered around the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, or AIPAC, in Washington, D.C., an organization that has been staunchly and unequivocally defending Israel's policies? What is it that makes J Street so unique to draw thousands of participants, many of whom come from the other states and places as far away as Jerusalem?
I attended most meetings of the conference for two-and-a-half days to receive answers to these questions. I met many ordinary participants as well as religious leaders, rabbis and humanitarian workers from Jerusalem. I met a couple of the participants during the "Jewish Community Town Hall" meeting, after speeches by Rabbi Eric Yoffie, the president of the Union for Reform Judaism and Jeremy Ben-Ami. After these speeches, the crowd discussed some of the questions of the ongoing conflict in Gaza and the Israeli-Arab peace process in general. Two participants were from Oxfam International, a confederation of 14 organizations working in more than 70 countries to find permanent solutions to poverty and injustice. One of these participants was John Prideaux-Brune, Oxfam's country director, who has been living in Jerusalem and Gaza for about five years.
John said that Israel still occupies Gaza from the sea, land and air, even if it claims officially it does no longer do so. According to the Geneva Conventions, Israel has to allow humanitarian help to enter Gaza. However, John argues, what is allowed to go into Gaza is incredibly limited. For example, macaroni cannot get in because it is considered a luxury food item. Israel only allows about 100 trucks of food to go in to Gaza a day, as opposed to 600-700 trucks before the Gaza conflict. Cement or any other construction materials are not allowed by the border officials as they could be used to make tunnels. His frustration goes further by talking about the terrible circumstances the Gazans live under; ordinary Jewish-American people also sitting at our table are equally angry and add their own criticisms to his frustrations. Another Jewish-American participant who is equally frustrated by the Israeli government's harsh treatment of the Gazan people was Naftali Kaminski, a doctor, who joined the conference from Pittsburgh.
Therefore, the first reason for J Street's success and wide popularity undoubtedly comes from the grassroots support of ordinary American Jews who are tired of Israel's grinding policies in Gaza and stubborn settlement practices. The grassroots support is, I believe, the most important element for any organization to be effective and apparently J Street has it all. There is another very important reason for J Street's immediate success, which is that it coincided perfectly with a new U.S. administration coming into office. J Street's close relationship with and support of the Obama administration was seen very clearly during the conference and this special relation apparently makes the organization’s mission to fill a gap in American politics even stronger. J Street defends many parallel policies that fit well with the Obama administration's plans, such as the two-state solution and a complete freeze of the settlements. It was also interesting to see that whenever a panelist talked about a two-state solution, criticized Israel for what it did during the last Gaza war or called for ending the occupation, the J Street crowd roared and applauded excitedly.
Even though J Street received heavy flak from AIPAC and other hard-line right-wing Israeli factions in respect to their criticism of Israel's policies, the open-minded discussions and honest debates on the panels were exhilarating and personally lifted my hopes for the peace process. To see a crowd in an inaugural conference describe themselves 'pro-Israel,’ but stand up against the country’s many wrong-headed policies gained my deep respect.
PS. Washington, D.C. marks its streets with letters, and J is missing from the actual map.
Monday, October 26, 2009
Evolution toward one worldwide religion
Friday, October 23, 2009
Is the Turkish opposition in peril?
HURRIYET DAILY NEWS
I have been writing for the Hürriyet Daily News for almost a year, and have heavily criticized a wide variety of the policies of the Justice and Development Party, or AKP, many times. I was raised, however, in an environment that was ideologically driven by Islam, the same roots as the AKP, so I now find it thrilling to watch the victories of these conservative Muslims from a distance.
And from this long distance, I have tried to understand what it must feel like to succeed in almost every development in today's Turkey after so many decades of feeling inferior. What I witness is an equally interesting parade. The conservative and religious segments of Turkey are flourishing at an ever-faster rate. This change, however, has not happened over night; on the contrary, it has taken place over years of meticulously prepared stages. The religious and conservative population of Turkey has worked hard and got richer. They have studied ardently, excelled in learning foreign languages and gained familiarity with the outside world, becoming much better accustomed to it than secular Turks. The conservatives, along with some pro-Islamic movements, adapted themselves to the times, polished their arguments and continued walking on a difficult path. Though they occasionally compromised on issues – and perhaps even lost some battles – they eventually came back to their original issues when they deemed the time appropriate.
Conservative Muslims in Turkey became well versed in Western pragmatism by excelling in their knowledge of the international arena, receiving every kind of degree in the West and establishing their own academic institutions in both there and here. They educated their own strategists, something Turkey has rarely seen. Rather than drafting policies with only today’s concerns in mind – as was the earlier custom – or simply being reactive in their foreign policy decisions, these strategists, whether one likes it or not, have drafted plans for the long term future because they now understand the region and the world better than before.
And today's administration in Turkey has been trying to bring some kind of compromise to issues that have dragged on for decades. For example, the Kurdish people, co-founders of the Republic, might now become a partner in the country again. This exciting new adventure might be to the advantage of Turkey. And it is a natural course as well because, when one looks at it closely, the love and the inseparable bonds between the two nations are just too powerful to be broken. This inseparability is, in essence, about to end terrorism in Turkey; the rest is mere politics. The present administration, despite its mistakes and shortcomings, is doing the right thing with this reconciliation process, regardless of whether it is with international help or because of the changing dynamics in Iraq.
Turkey has also been gaining the status of a regional power. The Arab world has started to appreciate our country. In this day and age, trade, rather than ideology, drives much of the foreign agenda. In many cases in fact, pragmatism is the driving force, not the other way around. No country conquers any other anymore, as hard power has proven fatal to the countries that resorted to that option in recent history. Instead, the power of the brain and of science has circumvented most of the problems between peoples and promises a better life. Even though ideologies appear to be on the rise in some parts of the world, in countries like Turkey, people who once had a taste of a better quality of life tend to make the most of this pragmatism and look for ways to continue on this road.
Could there be a dangerous turn of events along the way? Could this adventure be hijacked by the more extreme elements of some movement? Quite possibly. However, what we see today is a new generation of rich conservatives that are not the kind of people who want sharia law to be implemented in place of secularism.
In brief, whether it is the Armenian issue, or close relations with Syria, improving the lot of Kurdish people or supporting the unification process of Cyprus, it seems that the ruling party in Turkey is reading the region's affairs much better than the opposition parties.
What does this equation tell us? At present, there is no viable opposition party in today's Turkey that can challenge the AKP's foreign policies. Today the opposition in Turkey is lagging behind in terms of defending basic freedoms and understanding modern democracy. They have no ability to give lessons on the subject of a modern secular regime that treats its citizens equally and protects different societal segments from oppression by others. Turkey needs new and open-minded leaders who can elaborate ideas of social justice for its people.
Turkey needs an opposition party with at least a couple of experts in international foreign policy, so that every once in a while, they can show up in the capital of the United States, the center of world politics, and explain their stance on any given policy conflict. Sadly, the opposition argues that it does not need the backing of a foreign country; instead, just as in Ottoman times, it turns its back and says "istemezük/we don't want it" for almost every critical issue facing Turkey. As such, the conservative right is much better equipped to address these issues.
While freedom of the press is under enormous scrutiny – Reporters Without Borders, or RSF, ranks Turkey 122 out of 173 countries on this index and there are serious concerns about rising corruption – there is no opposition party in Turkey that has the credibility or the energy to discuss these issues with any manner of eloquence.
This said, I hope that pragmatism will prevail, and, based on technological innovations and the Internet, I hope too that Turkey's youngsters will have open hearts and minds and be able to meet their peers from around the globe with tolerance and compromise. They will learn that the good life is about living happily and enjoying things as much as one can while respecting others.
The evidence that this will happen in Turkey is "the moral direction in history," to quote U.S. author Robert Wright. This direction will once more prevail, and history will once more carry "human consciousness toward moral enlightenment, however slowly and fitfully." And for now, the best path toward such a future is the present administration, rather than the opposition. We will know when we find a viable alternative.
Monday, October 19, 2009
Win-win protocol (II)
Ilhan Tanir/Oguzhan Guler
HURRIYET DAILY NEWS
Russia's unexpected return to international power strongly displayed itself once more during the latest protocol discussions. Russia's unwavering role in urging the Armenian side to ink the protocols in Zurich, which is being widely reported in the Armenian and Russian press at present, confirmed its heavyweight status in the region and reaffirmed the Kremlin's decisive support for the restoration of relations between Armenia and Turkey.
For those who follow the international affairs of the region closely, it is unusual to see the unequivocal support all powers, the United States, Russia and the European Union, have given to the matter. However, this is the situation we presently face and this full support must be taken as great news in terms of a more stable and peaceful future for the southern Caucasus. One could point to many reasons as to why Russia has both been enjoying better relations with Turkey and supported the protocols; we, however, would like to emphasize one argument that failed to garner much attention – Turkey's position during the war last August between Georgia and Russia. During the war, Turkey utilized a balanced policy and showed a clear unwillingness to take an anti-Russian position along with the Western alliance. This was a turning point that brought Russia and Turkey closer than ever before.
During the conflict, Turkey denied passage to two U.S. ships through the Turkish Straits into the Black Sea, arguing that the ships violated the Montreux Convention which governs the traffic of military ships to the Black Sea. According to the convention, the tonnages of both of the two US ships well exceeded the limits allowed; as such, they were ineligible for passage.
Turkey, showing a full commitment to the Montreux Convention, received a warm response from the Kremlin. In our opinion, in addition to the increasingly strong trade relationship between the two countries that has made Russia Turkey’s biggest trade partner, a strategic, eye-to-eye understanding has been further solidified. This new partnership was consistently lauded during the Russian and Turkish leaders' numerous meetings both at the Kremlin and Ankara.
Still, even in the energy context, Russia sees the protocol results as a win-win situation, since such a multi-billion dollar and strategically important project like Nabucco will now have a bigger chance of passing through Armenia rather than Georgia, a country which the Russians still think should be punished further. And for that to happen, Armenia’s only chance to be part of the project is to have improved relations with Turkey.
It must be noted that Russia is not only popular in Yerevan, but also in Baku (it struck an important gas deal recently) and even in Kiev, where elections are scheduled for Jan. 17, 2010. The two main candidates, Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko and Victor Yanukovych, are both campaigning on a platform of building better relations with Russia in stark contrast to the last elections in 2004. The Ukrainian media have already ruled out the possibility of a second term for President Victor Yushchenko, the leader of the Orange Revolution. According to a poll conducted by the Ukraine Public Opinion Foundation, 26.8 percent of voters are ready to cast their votes in favor of Viktor Yanukovych, who was considered Russia's candidate during the last elections, against the current President Yushchenko's mere 2.2 percent poll rating.
From the American perspective, the protocol also promises a sunny future. According to Morton Abromowitz, the former U.S. ambassador to Turkey and a senior fellow at the Century Foundation, a Washington, D.C.-based think tank, restored relations between Armenia and Turkey was one of the two most important items on U.S. President Barack Obama's agenda when he visited Turkey in April. As such, the current developments should be seen as a great victory for America as well. America now sees benefits from a more stabilized region and Armenia, freed from the status of solely being Russia’s pawn, becomes a viable candidate to be part of an alternative energy route for the allies in Europe.
Obama will also have a great excuse to defuse the demands of the Armenian diaspora who want the American Congress to pass a resolution on the 1915 events in the coming year by highlighting the progressing relations between Armenia and Turkey. While the 2010 mid-term elections already loom for America, Obama does not wish to see another uproar by the strong and boisterous Armenian constituency in addition to many domestic problems.
On the other hand, in Azerbaijan, it seems that it all depends on the possible progress of the Nagorno-Karabakh dispute. For now, Azerbaijan’s leader İlham Aliyev does not see any reason to hide his skepticism; he is currently getting cozy with Russia by emphasizing the favorable transit prices Gazprom pays to Azerbaijan in contrast to the thriftiness of the Turkish brothers. This is the most worrisome piece of the equation, but for this very reason, it becomes a great incentive for Westerners to work harder to solve the dispute; otherwise, the only official gas source for the Nabucco line even becomes doubtful.
The biggest obstacle to the normalization of the relationship between Turkey and Armenia comes from the opposition parties in Armenia and from the diaspora. Two of Armenia’s leading opposition parties, the Dashnaktsutyun, or the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, and the Heritage Party, opposed the signing of the protocols and campaigned against it fiercely. President Serge Sarkisian visited Armenian diaspora communities throughout the world to gain their support, but was nevertheless greeted with protests. For the Armenian diaspora, it seems that the Armenians do not gain much by opening the borders, but lose a lot by opening a debate over the tragic events of 1915, which is an unforgivable betrayal. We feel it is inappropriate to take a stance against theirs because of the sensible nature of the subject alongside the arguments we have presented that would point to Armenia's future generations living a better life in a more prosperous country.
And the Turkish opposition? The National Movement Party, or MHP, and the Republican People's Party, or CHP, have opposed the protocols. It is very hard to understand and argue for or against their stance: It seems they have, unsurprisingly, not been able to elaborate their position eloquently as to why they would be against the protocols other than by showing their usual chauvinistic drama. And this is a sad fact for Turkey's opposition.
Friday, October 16, 2009
Win win protocol (I)
http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=win-win-protocol-2009-10-16
İlhan Tanır/Oguzhan Güler
HURRIYET DAILY NEWS
The much discussed protocol which foresees the normalization of the relationships between the Republic of Armenia and Turkey was signed in Zurich, Switzerland, last weekend.
The foreign ministers of the two countries, in the presence of the Minsk Group foreign ministers, were able to overcome the last minute 'ditch', which delayed the signing ceremony for hours. Consequently, this historic protocol which showed the long-term thinking ability of both sides, instead of yielding to an easy but meaningless pandering of short-term popular sentiments, prompted wide-range discussions within and without the region.
In Washington, DC, I recently had a chance to listen to the three former American ambassadors to Turkey talking about a range of issues related to Turkey. All three Ross Wilson, Marc Grossman and Morton Abramowitz, who sat for a series of interviews for "Studyo Washington", a daily news program on the Washington agenda which broadcasts from America's capital to Turkey for TRT Turk, and who collectively praised the new protocol and argued in various ways how important this protocol was as a way forward to solve complex issues between Turkey and Armenia, and also to prepare a productive terrain for geopolitical concert and regional stability.
The soccer diplomacy failed to carry either national soccer team to the World Cup finals, but was able to fortify a groundwork of diplomatic talks and finally to produce a protocol which promises mutual benefits in light of shared interests. And this makes observers and diplomats alike more hopeful for the ratification of the protocol, and subsequently for better prospective for strategic long-term stability. What has changed, and how have the two sides arrived here?
When one considers the starting point of this protocol as well as the hopes in the future for the restored relationships, the role of Justice and Development Party, or AKP, seems to have been the most important from the beginning. New Turkish foreign policies, such as disentangling historic conflicts with neighboring countries, coincided perfectly with President Obama’s coming into the office. US, exhausted in the region, became more open to such regional partnerships. Turkey's increased presence in regional strategic partnerships showed its self-confidence and therefore helped various parties to believe in Turkey's ability to take on such an historically difficult episode to work towards a peaceful reconciliation. Of course, there were also other variables to urge the Turkish officials to hasten the road map to better relations with Armenia. One obvious reason could have been Obama' s solid campaign promise to support a Congressional resolution that would recognize as genocide the tragic events of 1915. However, that would be immature to assess this development only and not taking into account Turkey's latest pro-active foreign policies in the region.
For Turkey, normalization of the relationship with Armenia is very important for a couple of major reasons: One is to ease the historic tensions by setting up commitees to look at the disputes, including the tragic events of World War I. It is known that the Armenian diaspora, which has a loud voice in various European capitals as well as in America, had became the biggest headache for the Turkish government over the last three decades along with the Cyprus issue. And the continuing assault on Turkey in the world gave Turkey a battered image. Whether or not the Armenian diaspora will be quieter is not known; however, setting up such a commitee to look into the troubling era will ease the jitters. The second is the possible progress on the Nagorno-Karabakh dispute, an enclave in Azerbaijan, through this bigger peace context. Finally, better relations with Armenia, and opening up the last closed border in the region is especially important for Turkey's newly gained image of being a good neighbor.
Armenia, economically one of the least developed countries in the former Soviet sphere, will benefit the most from the improved relations with Turkey. Reopening the borders will undoubtedly bring prosperity to the country with increased trade, and also a bigger chance for joining various regional energy and transport projects, which at the end will end up by further stimulating its economy. According to Vardan Ayvazyan, the head of the Armenian Parliamentary Committee on Economic Issues, reopening the border with Turkey will increase Armenia’s exports by 38% and its GDP will register a 3% growth. In the past, Armenia was bypassed in the multi-billion historical energy project, Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline, as a result of Turkish and Azerbaijani opposition, despite the fact that the shortest possible route was through Armenia and not Georgia. This pipeline route still looks like a scar over Armenia, and it still lingers as one of the biggest disappointments in memory. Now, at the dawn of another historic, as well as richer energy project, Nabucco, the Armenian government officials, in almost every possible occasion, clearly state their willingness to enter partnerships. Hopefully, the normalization of the relations and consequently solving the Nagorno-Karabakh dispute, will lead to such prosperous future.
Turkey, as is well-known, closed its borders with Armenia in 1993 to protest the illegal occupation of Nagorno-Karabakh and seven districts of Azerbaijan amounting to about a fifth of the Azerbaijani land. It should be known that it is not only Azerbaijan and Turkey, but also the United Nations, took the a similar stance in viewing the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict and has adopted the resolution #822 and followed it by three others: #853, #874 and #884, reaffirming the sovereignty and territorial integrity of the Republic of Azerbaijan. Turkey, as well as the international community, now wish that Armenia will comply with the UN resolutions. Although it is not an official pre-condition for normalization of the relations, one would predict that without progress on the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, it seems that there is little chance for the Turkish parliament to ratify the protocol. Therefore, not being able to resolve the Nagorno-Karabakh problem poses a real danger of getting the sides back to square one, after long months and even years of hard earned diplomatic gains and goodwill.
Next: Protocol from Russia and US perspective as well as the wider region. And where the Turkish and Armenian opposition stand.
Monday, October 12, 2009
The Nobel Peace Prize clash
Friday, October 09, 2009
All the President's generals
Monday, October 05, 2009
Iran looms larger on Turkey (II)
http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=iran-looms-larger-on-turkey-ii--2009-10-05
HURRIYET DAILY NEWS
Turkey, in terms of dealing with Iran, is one of the most unpredictable countries. Dr. Ahmet Davutoğlu, Turkey's foreign minister, and the architect of foreign policy for almost a decade now, also steers the Iran policy. Dr. Davutoğlu's intense lobbying for years toward a mediator role between Iran and the West has not been realized so far, amid not being given a chance to host the current on-going talks, which are being held in Geneva, instead of Istanbul.
We certainly should overcome this disappointment and try to analyze the latest developments around the Iranian nuclear program from Turkey's perspective, and luckily, we do have some recent concrete evidence to do so. It is Erdoğan's latest speech at the U.N. General Assembly. In his remarks, Erdoğan, while the discussion about the Iranian nuclear program has been buzzing in New York, chose to address mainly critiquing Israel's unjust war in Gaza, a war that happened almost a year ago but the effects of it still continue. I do think highly of Erdoğan's passionate plead for justice and pointing out the Gazans' poor living conditions, however, I do not understand why Erdogan has not added also the Uighur Turks' drama in China in recent months or great atrocities committed in Darfur as well, while he was on the subject.
Dr. Ibrahim Kalin, the top foreign policy adviser of Erdoğan, elaborated his boss' U.N. speech in his Oct. 3 weekly column in daily Sabah. In this column, Mr. Kalin mainly discussed the Goldstone Report, a report that is the U.N. Fact-Finding Mission on the Gaza Conflict mandated by the U.N. Human Rights Council and written by Richard Goldstone, an Israel-loving Jewish judge. This report determined that both Israel and Hamas had committed serious violations of the laws of war during the 22-day conflict in December and January, some amounting to war crimes and possible crimes against humanity. Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu himself publicly appealed to international leaders to reject the report as it accused heavily Israel's disproportionate assault in Gaza.
Turkey's statements over Israel are important while we discuss the Iranian nuclear program because the country that especially feels existential threat by the possibility of Iranian nuclear bomb is Israel. We must agree that if there was no Israel push against the Iranian nuclear program, there wouldn't be such an intense pressure from America either. Like Pakistan, Iran also would have had its own nuclear bomb, without getting into this much trouble.
On the other hand, while Erdoğan was bluntly addressing Israel's war crimes at the U.N. podium and devoted an important portion of his speech to beat Israel, Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu also gave a sparking and passionate speech against the countries that treat Iran softly: "Have those countries who did not abandon the U.N. Assembly when Ahmedinejad was talking (a day before) no shame?" Netanyahu asked and targeted therefore also Turkey, as one of those countries who didn't empty the room, during Ahmedinejad's speech.
In this case, an old Turkey, as a traditional American and Israel ally, would have been lined up behind these two countries against Iran. However, with the recent foreign policy orientation, thanks to Davutoğlu, Turkey has closed its ranks with Iran in recent years and the trade between two countries exceeded $11 billion from only $2 billion at the beginning of the decade. Turkey's energy dependence on Iran, as well as Russia, and Erdoğan's strong personal relations with Ahmedinejad and Putin also changed Turkey's classic alliance equation dramatically.
Turkey has been able to play an independent role in between the two worlds so far, however, one would certainly predict that this getting along with the two sides business, at some point, will come to an end. Turkey, since 2005-2006, amid lessening appetite for European Union reforms, and fastening relations with rogue regimes, has been creating many question marks amid Obama's hardened rhetoric against Iran, and possible vote to sanction Iran at the U.N. Security Council in the future. Even people like me, who appreciate the Justice and Development Party, or AKP, on many fronts as a much better alternative than the other opposition parties, have doubts over such a moment of truth.
Yes, the Iran episode looms large over many countries, but it does so much larger on Turkey. The policymakers and intellectuals, who tend to calculate the afterwards of the events, come to the conclusion that there is neither a viable military option available for Iran nor crippling sanctions. Iran's quest to nuclear power seems to be at an unstoppable stage, and many observers see nothing but a containment period looming over the relations with Iran.
While we are entering a possible period of deterrence, in which the West and the United States will try to isolate Iran as much as possible with the new Arab countries in the ranks, and work further to weaken the current Islamic regime with various ways as well as supporting the opposition in Iran, Turkey will not be able to maintain its close relationship ties with both sides, as was the case in recent years.
This looming containment period is expected to start sometime next year, if the current on-going talks in Geneva fail, as many predict. In light of the recent developments in New York, it has shown that Turkey has had a hard time convincing Iranians or the Western alliances about its trustworthiness when it comes to talking the vital issues. As one source who followed the U.N. and G-20 week in New York closely told me, Erdoğan learned about Iran's second secret uranium enrichment center of Qom with the rest of the world, meaning from television, when Obama, along with French and British leaders told the world. Therefore, it proved once more that Turkish officials were neither notified about the developments of this newly unearthed uranium facility by Iran, a country that hosts Turkish high officials very frequently, nor Turkey's biggest ally America, which learned about the nuclear facility officially through the International Atomic Energy Agency few days ago, but apparently they knew about it for months before.
In the coming times, amid being excluded from both sides, Turkey will have to choose to cooperate with one side. While Iran becoming an international castoff, and its current regime becoming a dictatorship, Turkey will have no other option but to join the international community. Even if Turkey currently seems unpredictable, and has a considerable dependence on Iran for energy and rising trade volume, Turkey's foreign policymakers, at some point, have to calculate their games according to the new power that will come to the helm of Iran, sooner or later.
Friday, October 02, 2009
Iran looms large (I)
http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=iran-looms-large-i--2009-10-02
HURRIYET DAILY NEWS
And the Iran showdown begins at last. It has been months that the interested parties, which is many, have been looking forward for this episode to set in.
Just a decade ago, America most definitely would have been the absolute dominator in such an impasse. At that time, America's ratings were shooting high off the chart, its economy was in its golden years, its military power was relentless, and its president, Bill Clinton, though troubled with the Lewinsky scandal at home, nevertheless was mostly adored by the rest of the world.
Around that time, America's moral credibility was also pretty high even within the Muslim world, thanks to bombing the Serbs, a non-Muslim nation, in Kosovo. America was able to influence regions and countries to solve small and big brawls as it wished. Iran, on the other hand, was just another rogue regime, nothing much less or more. After only less then a decade, today America has positioned itself badly in just about every conflict around the world. Various discords only work further toward eroding America's hard and soft power and moral credibility. In that respect, the result of America's general election last November, which brought to the helm a young and different leader, was the best result in retrospect, since it brought a fresh, likeable star presence to the top of the U.S. government and an attractive face to the world.
All the same, in these days, the weather of Washington is very bleak in many fronts at the same time. For example, the policy makers are debating endlessly what to do in Afghanistan. President Obama suddenly began to have second thoughts over his 'good war', the war for which only a few months ago he sent tens of thousands of troops to implement a new strategy. Instead he is now seriously thinking to reduce dramatically the US forces in the same theater. He did not even wish to see his commander's report on the war for a while, for he was contemplating a new strategy. Only when the military leaked the whole report to Bob Woodward, the favorite son of the American military, was he convinced to gather his top policy advisors to discuss it. Otherwise, according to the one good source in Washington, Obama was leaning to postpone the decision until the debates over the health care reform were over.
On the Arab-Israeli peace process front, Obama was supposed to not agree over anything short of a complete freeze of the Jewish settlements. Meaning all illegal settlements, including those in East Jerusalem, which, according to The Economist, are likely to become parts of Israel under a peace treaty, in return for land swaps as compensation. He went further to prove himself and adduced the settlements as preconditions for the peace process, which even the Palestinians were not much in the mood for in the past. Therefore, as The Economist argues, Obama tried to impose conditions that were practically impossible. The question is whether the advice he is receiving is terrible or whether he has a bit too much confidence in himself. At any rate, Obama's Palestine-Arab peace process drama's first curtain closes with great despair and loss. And he misses the chance of utilizing the gigantic support from the Muslim world, while it lasts.
And Iran. The mother of all conflicts. The Obama administration has not even had a chance to make a mistake on this front because Iranian diplomacy is just too perfect to give him such an opportunity. The only case that the Iranian regime seems not to have calculated was the elections and the tragic events that ensued thereafter. The Islamic regime was so sure that the elections were going to go smoothly that they even invited the foreign press to show off. Fortunately, the Iranian people surprised them.
The latest news shows that China will not go along with the severe sanctions on Iran if the ongoing talks fail, as America would have hoped. It becomes clearer that the Communist regime of Beijing has to quench the oil thirst that arises from of its growth, as many argue. As the second largest oil supplier of China, Iran also gives away billions of energy contracts on a golden tray to Chinese state energy companies. And the Chinese regime is just happy to get the whole Iranian pie for themselves and thanks Westerners for kindly staying away.
On the other hand, America, in reality, does not have the option for a military operation in Iran, and neither can it allow an Israeli attack. The U.S., as an occupier of two Muslim countries at the same time, does not have the stomach to attack yet another one. Obama, as a Democratic president who is in the White House to clean up his predecessor's mess, cannot start another war. Obama is in the White House to finish those two other inherited wars in the first place. Even if he wants to, the tarnished American military force and the gigantic budget deficit will not allow him, period.
Obama has had a dreadful first chapter of his presidency within and outside his country. The worst part is that he has not even shown his decision-making ability much. The first nine months of his presidency were supposed to be a honeymoon period to make a couple of good breakthroughs amid boundless support from the world.
To break this vicious circle of nine months, Obama has to get the Iranian conundrum right this time. That is the reason the talks in Geneva with Iran, since military operations impossible and sanctions are meaningless, seem to be the only options. America, having no other alternative but pray and support Iranian protesters to make further damage, will be the big loser if nothing comes out of these talks. So far, the news came out of the Geneva talks sounds too good to be true. I wonder what kind of surprise the Iranians have in store for the rest around this time.
Let's be realistic: We are in 2009, and America is not what it was just a decade ago. It lost much power, hence it has no other option but to go forward grudgingly with the talks. It seems the only hope we have that the Iranians will go along with the talks and comply with the Westerners' demands. But why, I must ask, should Iran give up on its decades-long nuclear ambition this time, especially when it seems the possibility is just within reach, and the adversary is in despair?
Next: Iran looms larger on Turkey
Monday, September 28, 2009
What G-20 Pittsburgh might have started
http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=what-just-g20-pittsburgh-might-have-started-2009-09-28
HURRIYET DAILY NEWS
The Group of 20 meeting in Pittsburgh was watched intensely around world last week. Even this wide recognition of the event tells most of the story. In the past, G-7 or G-8 meetings were not a part of the global excitement. During those G-8 meetings, the rest of the world, including developing countries, glanced at those gatherings and told each other what a snobby bunch those leaders were who got together just to brag about how rich they are and then smoked cigars over their medium-rare steaks.
I wrote the following after a conference in Washington, D.C., in the second week of January 2009, even before President Obama took office: " … Dr. Anne-Marie Slaughter [now the director of policy planning for the State Department] pointed out that the G-20 is expected to replace the G-8 to tackle the world’s important challenges. The group already started to work to confront the current global financial crises, and there will likely be other issues to follow, like climate change. … "
After only nine months, the G-20 became the new economic forum for world leaders to work and coordinate better economic policies so that they can offset some of the imbalances in the world economy that everybody seems to be complaining about in recent times. Therefore, these gatherings are not about only a few private clubs of rich nations anymore. With the G-20, which represents 85 percent of the world economy and about 60 percent of its population, is much more relevant to billions of people around world and will have a bigger impact over world affairs. So, when this “relevant” body got together last week, billions watched their own leaders as well as other leaders, and took pride as to how they are shaping the world.
Whether it was only this feeling of belonging to this important club that made the summit successful or whether it was something else is hard to predict, although it was obvious how the Group of 20 countries, from many parts and corners of the world, were able to formalize a “communiqué” that consists of a set of agreements in the form of a very significant message to the world.
For example, the major powers, or the Group of 8, let the discussions start to take some concrete steps to reach greater equality. Ever since my own college years, there have been talks about how the developing nations, especially China, India and Brazil, were lobbying for greater voice over the world economy and that they were not content with the current power distribution in the IMF or in other international economic bodies. And it seems, at last, they are harvesting the fruits of their long rallies, maybe just after lending so many hundreds of billions of funds to the United States.
This newly created international forum will start addressing mainly world's economic issues. Whether other issues will follow will mostly depend on how the new grouping works in the near future. It is very possible that last week's international dynamic shifting, in the future, can be seen as a cornerstone, while the history books will describe the 21st century events.
In this new history, the president of China scolded the American leader because of his protectionist policies. Mark McKinnon, from the DailyBeast, explained Obama's mistaken tariff policy and how his decision angered many American domestic sectors as well as foreign countries. This tariff hypocrisy, McKinnon argues, also conflicts with last April's G-20 summit. When Obama talked during his presidential campaign about how he would re-negotiate NAFTA for the American people's advantage, many found it laughable and did not care much since it seemed like just a populist argument. However, with this decision of adding more tariffs on Chinese tires, Obama might really buckle under the pressure of union workers, as many have suggested in the past.
Not everyone agreed on the success of the meetings, and there were many articles in which one could see the arguments about how toothless the Pittsburg meetings were. If nothing else, the meetings proved that the leaders of the world understand global interdependence. Yes, this newly created international cooperation was embraced because of fear and vulnerability, not because of confidence and strength.
Still, all members agreed that the current economic crisis is leading to much tighter regulations over financial institutions and that the bosses of those institutions must also be restricted over how much they can accumulate over a given period. This was a historic mark. The current economic downturn proved that in this global economy, if some of the biggest economies would not agree to tighten their financial sectors, this would be at the expense of others. For if many of those financial institutions were to move to more relaxed countries, they would do the same damage from there by taking enormous risks, as was the case for some time.
Both sides at the summit, meaning borrowers and lenders, promised to work toward balancing the world economy. On one side, America, as a leading borrower, promised that it would increase its savings rate and reduce its trade imbalance and, of course, will address its huge budget deficit. On the other hand, countries like China, Japan or Germany promised that they would not only try to allure other countries' consumers, but also strive to increase their own consumer spending and do not depend too much on American consumers. And yes, there is no binding resolution to condemn the poor sport countries. Though, with “peer reviews,” each country will submit its own homework to its friends and see how they do. And all will be reviewed by the International Monetary Fund.
The summit was a new paradigm to teach us how globalization has finally arrived. Over a couple of decades, globalization has been making headway and wiring everybody's life with head-spinning communication techniques, free movement of capital, etc. Now, it appears that global equality will be realized in a more democratic way. This could be the beginning of the worldwide government Inc. And happily, Turkey, with its rising importance and big economy, will take part in this new world order.
Friday, September 25, 2009
President Mehmet Ali Talat: I don't think so
A week before Talat’s arrival in the United States, Suat Kınıklıoğlu, a member of Parliament and deputy chairman for external affairs for the Justice and Development Party, or AKP, and spokesman of the foreign affairs committee of the Turkish Parliament, published a very serious opinion piece titled "It's now or never in Cyprus" on the ongoing Cyprus debate in the British daily Guardian.
The article attracted some attention with its blunt language about the talks regarding the unification of Cyprus. Kınıklıoğlu, in his opinion piece, first argued that the new negotiation process for the island, initiated by the U.N. in 2008, was fully “blessed” by the AKP leadership. He continued to say that 2009 is going to be a-make-it-or-break-it year for Cyprus.
"It should be clear that the current talks are the last chance for a negotiated settlement on the island. The outcome of the ongoing talks, for example, will have a big impact on how Turkey assesses its relations with the EU. Should the talks fail, the side that behaves in an uncompromising manner will bear full responsibility for dividing the island forever,” he said.
The emphasis on the word “forever” is worth paying attention to. Since Mr. Kınıklıoğlu is an important voice within the Turkey’s ruling party, his opinion piece should be taken as the party’s official stand and naturally this stance bears many ramifications for the current process.
Just prior to this opinion piece published in the British daily, on Sept. 10, Döndü Sarıışık of Hürriyet Daily News reported that the first-ever visit by a high-ranking Turkish diplomat to the self-proclaimed Abkhazia Republic has boosted the breakaway republic's hopes of being recognized by Turkey. Sarıışık's report came the same day Venezuela recognized Abkhazia as the third country in the world, after Russia and Nicaruga.
According to an expert in Washington, D.C., who follows Turkish affairs closely, the AKP leadership is in danger of losing the support of Turkish nationalists in north and central Turkey to the Nationalistic Movement Party, or MHP, because of its Kurdish opening. At the same time, the AKP may also be losing some support in the south and the west to the Republican People’s Party, or CHP, as the last local general elections confirmed.
According to this expert, however, the AKP cannot backtrack on the Kurdish opening at this stage, as it might create a backlash within its own party and voter base. The talks are supported by a majority, as well as by Turkey's liberal wing and the European Union's officials, who closely monitor the current talks. Therefore, facing the possibility of losing support on many fronts while moving closer to general elections in 2011, the AKP may feel inclined to turn to the Cyprus issue to regain the support of Turkish nationalists, a segment that was a significant part of the AKP's winning coalition in the last general elections.
For his part, Talat was unwilling to address a possible scenario involving ending the ongoing talks in his conversations in Washington, as Kınıklıoğlu appeared to suggest in his article. Still, Talat said he did not get such an impression while he was communicating with Turkish officials. In contrast, he added, in recent visits to Ankara he was assured by the highest level of Turkish leaders that Turkey's support for the talks would continue.
Talat also eloquently elaborated that Turkish officials are well aware of the fact that with the Turkish side voting “for” the unification of the Island in the 2004 referendum in Cyprus, in contrast to the “no” vote of the Greek side, Turkey has gained an enormous leverage and momentum in the international arena on many fronts at the same time. Turkey, after its courageous supportive role in that peace process and its consequent push for the unification, elevated its standing in the European Union accession talks and was subsequently granted a full membership candidate status. With its rising profile in the international arena and in the region, Turkey found it easy to lobby for membership of the United Nations Security Council and to then get elected for the seat after many decades, primarily because of its relatively relaxed standing with the consensual approach it has taken before and during the Cyprus referendum.
In short, President Talat does not think Turkey would take the risk to forget everything about unification talks if things went not as well as hoped for in 2009. He thinks, Kınıklıoglu's scenario of “now or never” would cause Turkey to lose too much of the terrain gained in recent years through its positive role in the Cyprus issue. Although he did not say it, one of the areas that would surely be affected adversely is Turkey's relationship with the EU.
However, according to recent news reports regarding Turkey's possible recognition of Abkhazia, other reports suggest that Russia will reciprocate by recognizing Northern Cyprus as a separate and independent country. If that were to happen, Russia would be the first one to recognize it after Turkey. Turkey has been improving its relations with neighbors such as Russia, Iran and Syria and if Kınıklıoğlu's warning about the implications of a deadlock in the ongoing talks is serious then Turkey may well be tempted to use such relationships in charting a radical new course in Cyprus.
Tuesday, September 22, 2009
Why the AKP's leadership may be wrong for today's Turkey
HURRIYET DAILY NEWS
The title of the column may sound irksome especially while discussing the current talks of Kurdish opening. It is hard not to agree with those folks actually, for Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is the only prime minister since Turgut Özal who seems to understand the urgency of the Kurdish problem, the problem that has been bleeding too long. One must be ignorant at best not to see it.
One could still be ignorant and continue to play the same old politics, as it had happened since Özal up to now and inflict every kind of pressure to keep this wound frozen. It has proved, however, that inaction is not a politically preferable solution either, since those who showed ignorance of the problems in the Kurdish conundrum have been eliminated or rejected by the voters and erased from the political arena.
Therefore, Erdoğan, by taking this enormous political risk, shows how powerful his political instincts and political caliber are, which the country rarely has ever seen. And he should be credited for his courage to open talks, regardless of what his political thoughts might be. Today, Turkey is a country where politicians who administer the country take political risk by trying to bring some consensus to the table in order to solve the Kurdish issue, but the opposition, those who do not have any risk save adding one more election in their losing streak, at worst, still prefer to play safe and advocate the status quo.
There are not many countries one can imagine where the opposition parties oppose change, and the ruling party works for a change. Amid this equation, the Justice and Development Party, or AKP, distinguishes itself from the opposition parties, and proves it is better than other current alternatives.
However, the leadership of the AKP, while having all those great bonuses, seems to lack the understanding of today’s modern concepts of civil liberties and of those of the coming age. There are many missing elements in their vision that makes this leadership incapable of comprehending some of the basic tenets of civil liberties. Many of them are unable to see and understand what exactly is the meaning of living together under a secular state where religious, cultural, ethnic and political specificities are fully respected, since they did not live in or study such a society to excel the understanding of how such system works in other countries. AKP's leadership might be one of the last of the old generation of politicians who is well capable to deal with his country's economic and political problems, though when it comes to bring comprehensive and contemporary answers to social problems, this leadership has not enough experience to apply.
At the beginning of this column I complimented Erdoğan's courageous attempt to tackle the Kurdish issue, whatever the real reasons of these talks might be. However, for the reasons I mentioned above, it is doubtful that AKP has a vision of solving this historic issue. For example, it is not known whether the potential problems of giving collective rights to the Kurdish people of Turkey have been thoroughly examined, as Soner Cagaptay recently argued in this newspaper. Cagaptay rightly argued that assigning exclusive ethnicity-based group rights to the Kurds might further strengthen and solidify the Kurdish identity, and what is worse, increase the distance between the Kurds and the rest of the country's population. This would challenge the established social and historic proximity between the Kurds and other groups. Cagaptay's arguments have not received deserved credit or reaction as a unique approach that has not been seen much during months long debate over these opening talks. Whether this argument did not attract much attention because of Cagaptay's hard rhetoric toward AKP, or whether it was because the basic premise of the column, which is the rights of all, is too much to ask for the current administration remains to be seen.
The AKP started a road of opening to talk about a very important issue that it may not be capable of pursuing, because of the defect the leadership of the party has in its understanding of the gamut of civil liberties that have come to be known as basic civil rights. Those are the rights that set limits on the government so that its members cannot abuse their power and interfere unduly with the lives of private citizens; that is to say, freedom of religion, freedom of speech, due process of law, the right to privacy and so forth. Once a society is raised in terms of its basic human rights, meaning all groups, not only one group, it is a promise that much of the problem that long persist will go away.
With the latest row over the tax fine on Doğan Media Group, this leadership also once more has proven that they are unable to see the basic premise of the institution of the right to freedom of expression, as well as how a secular government should treat all its people or companies equally, without undue and discriminatory interference.
Erdoğan, when explaining his argument for the tax fine levied upon Doğan Media Group, stated that the press should not think itself above the law. However, Erdoğan fails to explain how it is exactly that the press imagines itself above the law. How can we separate that thin line so that the media can learn not to regard itself above the law, so that it would not do so ever? That could have been a great service for the media, if Erdoğan explained that separation as well.
I know this argument simplifies the problem a little; however, I still believe very much that one of the basic reasons why the leadership of the AKP fails to understand the basic premise of freedom of speech is because many of the top cannot read and listen to how the Western media treats its governments and what kind of criticism the leaders of the modern world have to endure every day to pursue their agendas. Consequently, whatever this leadership seems to know or think about freedom of expression and press usually is in the wrong tone. Yes, I do not believe Erdoğan knows what that thin line is, nor do I think he or many in AKP's top leadership are aware of other countries' examples to make sound judgment over the issue.