twitter

Monday, August 08, 2011

A week of cautious optimism for Turkish-Israeli relations

http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=a-week-of-cautious-optimism-for-turkish-israeli-relations-2011-07-22

There is cautious optimism in the air right before Turkish and Israeli officials meet once more this weekend in New York City to see if they can find appropriate language to patch up their much-damaged relations. The release of the U.N. Palmer Report, the investigation into the 2010 Gaza Flotilla incident, is likely to be delayed until July 27 – making it the effective ‘’deadline’’ for Israel to issue an apology over the incident.
Most of the Israeli government officials who opposed the notion of an apology in the past shifted their position with the notable exception of the radically right-wing Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman. While some argued that Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s potential visit to Gaza might be another sticking point, the Israeli Embassy in Washington rejected this notion and told me that “this visit can be arranged between Turkey and Egypt, and Turkey doesn’t have to coordinate it with Israel.”
Israel, following active diplomatic lobbying, was able to avoid a second wave of flotillas, though it is losing a bigger PR battle in the eyes of the international community. It appears to be pushing forward with settlement expansion at full speed in occupied territories while passing undemocratic laws: like the anti-boycott law that effectively bans any public call for a boycott against Israel or any area under its occupation.
All the while, increasing demands for freedom, democracy and self-rule by Arab peoples across the region are creating an enormous challenge and need for the Israeli government to accommodate the Palestinians’ demand for a just state. Washington is also well aware that the unresolved Palestine-Israeli conflict negates much of the goodwill put forward by President Barack Obama through his conciliatory attitude toward the Muslim world. Just this week, a Zogby poll put the Obama administration’s approval ratings below the 10 percent threshold – even worse than that of the previous administration.
On the other hand, the Arab Spring so far has proven to be an effective factor pushing Washington and Ankara closer, and Ankara’s rhetoric has fallen in line with Washington’s on the brutalities of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad’s regime – something that has created friction in Ankara-Tehran relations. Washington, especially following the Justice and Development Party, or AKP’s, sound election victory, is doing everything not to infuriate Ankara and crowned the good relations with the successful secretary-of-state visit last week.
Another reason for optimism at this time for Turkey-Israel relations is the very effective Jewish-American organizations’ change of stance toward the AKP government. David Harris, the executive director of the American Jewish Committee, stated, ‘’Arab Spring once more proves the significance of the Turkey-Israel relationship…which has natural affinity,’’ while it showed how problematic Ankara’s close relations are with the Assad and Moammar Gadhafi regimes. Abraham Foxman, the national director of the Anti-Defamation League, or ADL, in another interview said, “Now the elections are over and it is time to build the relations... Erdoğan is a good person... we are optimistic and we hope that tensions, also for the Turkish-Jewish people for some time, will end.”
Ari Goldberg, a spokesperson of the AIPAC, a powerful and conservative Israeli lobby, one that had especially problematic relations with the AKP said, “Both of us want to put the ugliness of the last year behind. It is time for this relation to go forward.”
Both sides, so far, appear to want to repair relations for various reasons, in addition to the strong push by Washington, which spent a considerable amount of time mending the ties between its friends in the last two years.
Better relations with Israel can create an opportunity and give leverage to Turkey to contribute to the peace process, which would also do much to synchronize all three governments’ efforts to actively support the region’s demand for democracy and freedom against undemocratic rulers.

 
22 Comments   Bookmark and Share  printer friendly PRINTER FRIENDLY

READER COMMENTS




Guest - Saliha
2011-07-29 02:04:04
Israel Apartheid? Give me a break! Arabs are 20% of the population, are full citizens w/same rights as Jews, serve in the military, are Members of Parliament, University Presidents,etc. Palestine/Arab states are Apartheid... no Jews even allowed!



Guest - Chris Athens
2011-07-24 23:17:47
@ Murat since you seem so sensitive about civilian blood, should I assume that you expect killers of Tassos Isaac and Solomos Solomou (Cyprus 11/8/1996) to face the court too, or your sensitivity is conveniently selective?



Guest - Thessalonian
2011-07-24 21:27:47
Once again Erdogan cuts off his nose attempting to discipline others. Cyprus, EU and the Israel. He does however have a good relationship with Iran's Ahmadinejad, Syria's Assad and Libya's Gadhafi and Palestine's Hammas. Way to go Turkey!



Guest - ManInTheMiddle
2011-07-24 18:53:24
@Danny, it must have gone over your head but Syria and Libya have never claimed they are democracies, value human rights, and share "western values"! Israel, as a Jewish Apartheid, keeps making those claims. BTW, your bigotry slip is showing.



Guest - Strange are Iranian less worth
2011-07-24 18:41:18
Murat. The Iranian regime, with its Moral Police, is making life miserable for millions of Muslims. The conditions in prisons are horrible and include torture and rape. But I can not recall that you shout the same hate against Iranian government.



Guest - Yitzhak
2011-07-24 17:11:50
When Turkey apologizes to Armenians, Greeks, Pontians, Syriacs, Cypriots and others it Ethnically Cleansed, then Israel may apologize for Mavi Marmara. Turkey has many more apologies to deliver than Israel, Mr. Erdogan. Your hands are not clean.



Guest - Yaacov
2011-07-24 17:07:33
Most Israelis could care less about a relationship with Turkey. That nation is becoming the second Iran in the region under PM Erdogan. He's an Islamic extremist. Turkey should apologize to Israel for Davos, first.



Guest - Murat
2011-07-24 12:30:21
It stands to logic that the party with blood of civilians on their hands should do more to reconcile. Too late for apologies. Killers should face a real court.



Guest - ALI
2011-07-24 11:40:49
The new Turkish foreign policy in the regıon, requires them to support the values ​​of freedom and justice, thus supporting Palestine .. Death to the occupation and the system of racism



Guest - devy Wolff
2011-07-24 09:52:10
F.M. Avigdor Lieberman "radically right wing", you make me laugh. He is an israeli patriot and articulates the truth, wether you turks like it or not. The UN report will show the facts. No need for any apology.



Guest - Canuck
2011-07-24 07:01:16
For an apology, what is Israel getting in return from Mr. Erdogan "Pasha". - Zero! If so - it is Zero- apology he deserves and gets.As far as the Gaza trip- Enjoy your stay.



Guest - john inverness
2011-07-23 20:15:06
Erdogans demands for an apology serve to undermine him, Turkey provoked and started all this with Israel. Turkey is its own worst enemy. Where will relations deteriorate next I imagine. Likely within Turkey herself.



Guest - Mah
2011-07-23 19:59:28
Erdogan, pl. do not antagonize jews. Reconcillation would help Turkey, if not Israel. Jews are very intelligent, educated, and well off people - muslims have a lot to learn from them.



Guest - Kahan
2011-07-23 19:52:28
Mark, you are right. Let us be honest - Muslims are the greatest problems for muslims. They are in disarray; they kill one another; they do greatest harms to other muslims. They lack education, science, engineering, develpment.



Guest - SB
2011-07-23 19:07:03
DANNYB-Syria and Libya are not occupiers.IAN-Turkey was the first Muslim country scolded the Assad regime. JIM-If then why Obama,Hillary,and Petreus visited Turkey?MIKE-your numbers are right,but Russians picked up the slack.JD-you're lacking logic.



Guest - Bronxman
2011-07-23 15:11:20
Given the instability of most countries in the Middle East a rapprochement would definitely benefit both countries and the region. The alternative would have a strong negative impact.



Guest - Danny B
2011-07-23 14:42:36
Jan: it just shows the hypocrisy of the Muslim world, while they call Israel as Apartheid country, murderers and ethnic cleaners , they kill each other with great success. Didn't see Syrian or Libyan flags burning in the streets like Israeli flag.



Guest - ian
2011-07-23 11:13:02
wheres turkeys pm and public in regard to the daily massacres happening in syria wheres the anger the street demonstrations the public outcry the indignation the burning of flags. muslims killing muslims . doesn't really rate



Guest - Jim Hale
2011-07-23 07:52:24
Not sure what unreality this author lives in. Ankara and Washington are not close at all. Israel has stated it will not apologize nor should they, and finally the Palestinians are the main problem towards a peace agreement not the Israelis.



Guest - BlueMike
2011-07-23 02:00:02
Rapprochement is more important to Turkey than to Israel. Turkey lost 200,000 Israeli tourists and watches a new relationship between Israel and Greece. The UN Mavi Marmara commission will exonerate Israel. Mr. Erdoan had led Turkey into disaster.



Guest - Mark
2011-07-23 01:23:46
Where is turkey when million of Muslim Somalian suffers the worst drought in more than half a century, where today only Christian people gelling out these people. What is the different between Palestinian & Somalian isn't both muslim?



Guest - jdenver
2011-07-23 00:31:18
Is this the best logic you have for Turkey's side? Turkey should apologize for sending a ship of terrorists to Israel and Israel will NEVER trust Turkey again. The AKP has alienated the EU, the US and Israel. Stay in your neighborhood.

Turkey, evolution toward a regional power

http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=turkey-evolution-toward-a-regional-power-2011-07-01

Friday, July 1, 2011
Whether the West lost Turkey was one of the main discussion topics in Washington as of last year. Turkey’s close Iran relations, and its vote against the strong will of the U.S. at the United Nations Security Council in the case of sanctions against Iran, appalled many observers at the time. Terrible relations with Israel were another element of Turkey’s foreign policy that the U.S. administration took great issue with.
Since the Arab Spring began, discussions about Turkey have changed dramatically in Washington. Turkey’s Muslim background and multi-party democracy ushered it in as an actor that is most valuable in the East for the West, and versa. President Barack Obama’s frequent calls to Ankara or U.S.’ constant embracing toward Ankara’s Syrian policy are two current samples to prove that value.
While Turkey is enjoying its regional popularity, the region’s other rival powers in the region, such as Iran, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Israel, appear to be on the losing side of the big transformation. Egypt, as the largest Arab country, is going through a revolution itself and will be extremely busy in years to come to sort out its complicated political, economic, security issues and many others.
Iran, for a while, tried hard to cast itself as supportive of the protesters in relatively distant places, such as Libya or Egypt. Although its rhetoric suddenly became a gross hypocrisy when it backed the Syrian regime’s cracking down on the same demands of freedom. Sanctions continue to weaken the Islamic regime, as the increasing demand for democracy in the region sheds more light on Iran’s own democratic deficits.
The Arab Spring also isolated Israel further by pushing out Hosni Mubarak, its stable ally. Now, while Israel is trying to stop Palestinians from going to the U.N. for recognition, it feels great pressure under Obama’s moderately tough 1967 line rhetoric.
Gen. Brent Scowroft, national security adviser to presidents Gerald Ford and George H. W. Bush, in an interview in his office a block from the White House, told me that the “dissent or the growing hostility [against U.S.] in the region really comes from what they [Arabs] see as U.S. support for Israel as much as anything else. We are identified with our support to Israel’s subjugation of Palestinians.”
According to Scowcroft, as he reflected the thoughts of an important part of foreign policy elite in Washington, “because of injustice that the Arabs and Palestinians perceive, while they try to get rid of oppressive regimes through protests in various states, they also appear to want to get rid of this injustice... I think that sense of injustice is a deeper sentiment of the Arab Spring than the demands for democracy.” Israel has increasingly felt like “a rejected son of Middle East” throughout the revolts, as one well-placed Israeli expert stated this week.
On Iran, Scowcroft finds Turkey’s policy “complex, but at its heart, not that different [from the U.S.]. Turkey benefits economically from this relationship, however, fundamentally, Tehran and Istanbul are opposite poles. You cannot just wish this fact to go away. Turkey might help us more through working with Iran rather than reflecting U.S. hostility on them.”
Scowcroft, whom until a year ago was the chairman of the American-Turkish Council, thinks that Turkey is finding its natural course and the U.S. should support and understand it. Atatürk, Scowcroft argues, took the Ottoman religious/political state and tore it apart, and established a secular democracy in its place, “which he felt that he had to impose this to take the Turkish attitude to a more normal state.”
Scowcroft has also many misgivings over the ruling Justice and Development Party, or AKP’s, mixed performance over freedom issues and seemed not sure which direction Turkey is going: more democratic or more authoritarian. And he doesn’t think that after almost a decade of AKP rule, this enigma is not unusual.
Needless to say, this evolution can be completed only if/when Turkey solves its own constitutional questions and elevates its own democratic standards.

 
3 Comments   Bookmark and Share  printer friendly PRINTER FRIENDLY

READER COMMENTS




Guest - Kangaroo
2011-07-06 05:38:23
  US ties with Israel will dimisi in time as there is no value in keeping Israel as an ally within the region. The dominant factor is Turkey.  



Guest - ahmet
2011-07-03 20:52:00
  Turkey is enjoying its regional popularity...as far as the Arabs are concerned. If only Turkey had popularity among Europeans.  



Guest - ron
2011-07-02 20:51:05
  empire nations never stop being empires......they take breaks....turkey is ona break. egypt is on brake. so are others.... ron usa

Monday, June 27, 2011

Washington and Ankara meet on idealism towards Syrian uprising

http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=washington-and-ankara-meet-on-idealism-towards-syrian-uprising-2011-06-26

Sunday, June 26, 2011

Turkey’s Ambassador to Washington Mr. Namık Tan, concluded his speech at the Middle East Institute’s second annual Turkey conference with probably the most universal note used by a Turkish official. “Turkey will never let tyranny prevail over democracy and freedom.”
Turkey’s “zero problems with neighbors” policy for the last eight years under the directions of Dr. Ahmet Davutoğlu, on the contrary, would be described by and large as a realist one.
It can be argued that Ankara’s realist approach towards stability in the region continued through the first weeks of the Libyan upheaval. In the beginning of March, when Amb. Selim Yenel, deputy undersecretary for Public Diplomacy, was visiting Washington right about the time Moammar Gadhafi’s forces began his move to crash evolving rebel forces. Yenel’s message to Washington was: “We have to look out for our interests there... saying certain things are good, but living in the real world, of course our approach and our policies have to gear toward this realism.”
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s chief foreign policy adviser Mr. İbrahim Kalın also carried similar messages to Washington in the past. During a conference in Washington right before the Arab Spring started, Kalın was very much unwilling to talk about Turkey’s such moral role in discussions and considered related questions in terms of “democracy promotion,” a bad reminder of Bush’s Middle East foreign policy.
Last week though Kalın was much more forthright in Washington while talking about Turkey’s moral standing. Arab governments that will be “more democratic, transparent, that uphold the rule of law, human rights and prosper; will not be against our interests... because this is what Turkey wants to do... relations with the neighbors in the region,” Kalın remarked while explaining why Turkey will be straightened, not weakened, by the Arab Spring.
According to Kalın, another reason Ankara will be winner in the end is because Ankara is the only capital that has developed special relations both with region’s leaders and people, through hosting various opposition groups and continuing dialogue with Hezbollah, Hamas or Muslim Brotherhood.
For whatever the reasons are, Ankara’s newly pro-change posture is highly appreciated by the United States administration, in which Ankara applies one of the harshest languages in the region towards Damascus.
To set the record straight, it was not only Ankara who was pursuing a “stability first” attitude in the region. In 2009, newly elected President Barack Obama, all of a sudden, found his administration in a situation to deal with the Iran’s post-election unrest when Obama’s realist foreign policy was distancing itself from the “maligned” Bush’s idealist Middle Eastern policy. To undo the Bush years, Obama sought to repair somewhat strained relations with Egypt’s Hosni Mubarak, started an encroachment with Bashar al-Assad, while downplaying the protests in Iran.
Nowadays, Obama’s June 2009 big speech in Cairo or Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s warning remarks in Doha addressing the region’s governments, which took place just about 10 days before the revolution started in Egypt, are the rare idealistic moments that the U.S. officials now can cling to while looking back.
Instead, as the Arab Spring tumbled several dictators, Washington rapidly swung towards idealistic tones, both in the beginning of the Libya operation and when he laid out his administration’s Middle East vision in May.
It is obviously not a given result that Ankara’s or Washington’s increased idealistic voices or their current pressing arguments against Syrian regime will pay off quickly. Social, economic and political shortcomings of the Arab nations, as many political scientists argue, indeed reasons for all to worry in the short term results.
Still, instead of supporting despotic regimes and being deceived by a fake stability, Ankara and Washington increasingly appear to believe that gone are the days of providing zero problems to despots.
It is not a bad policy change at all.

 
2 Comments   Bookmark and Share  printer friendly PRINTER FRIENDLY

READER COMMENTS




Guest - dd
2011-06-27 14:11:52
  turkey has a long way to go to satisfy EU desires  



Guest - Fahd alharby, Madina, S Arabia
2011-06-27 02:15:19
  Turkey has an excellent chance after the early stumble in Libya,Syria is a strategic opening for Turkey to Contribute by kicking Assad out

Foreign policy implications of Turkish elections

http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=foreign-policy-implications-of-turkish-elections-2011-06-19

Sunday, June 19, 2011


Washington, like many other capitals across the world, continued to discuss the impressive victory of the Justice and Development Party, or AKP, throughout the week.
“I met [PM Recep Tayyip] Erdoğan twice and I would have also voted for him, if I could,” said Steven Cook, one of the Turkey observers, who recently raised many eyebrows in Ankara by his “Arab Spring, Turkish Fall” catchy article, in which he argued that the enormous change in the Arab countries proved that Ankara has no special insights into the region compared with the West, as the leaders of AKP argued for years.
Fifty percent of the vote, as would have given to any other administration, also gave a clear mandate and confidence to the AKP leadership. While across the Middle East, from Iran to Egypt, Morocco to Saudi Arabia, the regimes are bumping into all kinds of stability troubles, having concluded a fair and free elections, Turkey once more distinguished itself from the bunch and reminded all why Turkey matters so much to the Arab Spring.
Therefore, it can be argued that the June 12 election has not changed enough of the dynamics in Ankara to make us believe that Turkey will withdraw from its pro-active ambitions. Turkish activism has to continue and the static diplomacy of the Cold War is out of the question, most would argue, because of the location it occupies, the history it relates to and the largest economic clout in its region, regardless of any particular administration.
Erdoğan’s “balcony speech” on election night should have erased any doubts on this subject. Bülent Alirıza, the Turkey project director at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, or CSIS, told me to pay attention to those victory greetings that were sent from Erdoğan to several cities in the region, and argued that Washington must have caught what all this universalist tone should encompass about Ankara’s future foreign policy desires.
Ankara’s attitude, when it comes to bloody crackdowns in Syria, became unusually aggressive as well. Ankara hosted the Syrian opposition figures, helped them to organize, condemned Damascus for its “savage” actions and opened its borders to thousands of refugees who are fleeing from Bashar al-Assad’s ruthless forces.
As if Ankara, with its outspoken demeanor toward the Assad regime, tries to erase some of the bad memories left behind from the Libya experience, during which Ankara was equally hesitant and unwilling to join to the international consensus to stop Moammar Gadhafi’s ferocious behavior. The U.S. State Department for the whole week has done nothing but praised Turkish open border policy and reiterated its support.
Erdoğan, while urging Assad to reform, has not chosen to isolate him yet. Richard Armitage, chairman of the American-Turkish Council, or ATC, and former deputy to the Secretary of State, while arguing this point over the phone also claimed that “the zero problem policy is now outdated by what is taking place in especially Syria.”
Even though Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu himself, in recent interviews, described the “zero problem policy” as not an absolute goal, but a mere struggle to change the old-state-mindset that considers “all neighbors as enemies,” the policy is widely understood and accepted as mainly as a stabilizer reflection of the Turkish foreign policy, in which Ankara prefers dictators over unstable democratic demands.
Another Turkey observer who argues that the change in the Arab world showed the limits of Turkish policy is Henri Barkey, at the Carnegie Endowment. According to Barkey, Turkey’s Middle East policies hit the wall with the Arab Spring. Barkey concluded in an interview that Turkish election results will not change much in the region because the Arab world itself is undergoing historic change, and Ankara like other capitals has no silver bullets to give any particular direction to a still much-unknown region.
According to the latest Gallup poll conducted in March-April in Egypt, Egyptians, overwhelmingly, want to create their own political path and are not in a mood to borrow from anyone else’s. Mohamed Younis, a senior analyst at the Gallup Center in Washington, argued this sentiment while sharing with me with the unpublished piece of the survey that relates to Turkey. According to this survey, only 2 percent cited Turkey as a political model for Egypt. On a side note, only 15 percent of Egyptians approve of Turkish leadership, 47 percent disapprove following the revolution.
Sunday’s elections proved how efficient and skillful the ruling party is. Erdoğan changed the rules of politics by increasing his party’s share in the votes for the third consecutive time and challenged the many widespread assumptions of old times.
A hundred years ago, the Ottoman Turkish Empire, under attack from Europe’s nationalistic sentiments in the preceding century, was at a breaking point while struggling to pay its foreign debt and to contain self-determinism.
A hundred years later, freedom, democracy and individual empowerment are the new rules of globalization, and Turkey this time around is positioning itself to reap the best long-term strategic advantages against its regional rivals, like Iran and Saudi Arabia, mainly because of its own democratic experience.
Finally, by writing and adapting a liberal, egalitarian and inclusive constitution, Turkey would guarantee to be driving aspirant of the more democratic region for years to come.
It is time Turkey cleaned its own house by setting the democratic standards much higher. If Erdoğan indeed leads such a process, as Cook said, “He can seal his place in history.”