twitter

Thursday, July 01, 2010

Ankara's Washington misreading

The flotilla attack, which turned out to be one of the saddest events of the Republic of Turkey's recent history, still produces consequences in the Middle East and beyond.
Following the attack, Turkey waged a diplomatic war against Israel with every possible instrument that it held in its disposal. Billions worth of military contracts and joint military exercises are canceled, the Israelis started to boycott the Turkish goods along with sending dramatically fewer tourists to Turkey. The leaders of the Justice and Development Party, or AKP, have uttered the heaviest words possible in the international diplomacy arena against Israel since then, and received equally harsh responses from Jerusalem.
Turkey, in the days that imminently followed the flotilla attack, rightly, acted crossly and mobilized the international bodies to punish Israel. Israel failed to confront the aid ships safely and it will, at some point, have to accept its responsibilities in killing 9 people. In light of this disproportionately heavy intervention by the Israeli Navy commandos, various international actors rallied behind the Turkish position, along with the majority of public opinion.
It can be well argued, on the other hand, that the Erdogan government used the flotilla crisis to the limit to exploit it for its own domestic and foreign political gains as well. Sadly, it seems that the hard-hitting rhetoric against Israel is politically very convenient in Turkey, because there are so few minorities left to demonstrate any meaningful backlash against those populist orators.
The leadership of the AKP, however, did not stop with waging a diplomatic war. Instead, Ankara chose to cut about all its diplomatic and intelligence ties, most importantly back channel exchanges of information with Jerusalem. The new head of the Turkish Intelligence Service, or MIT, Mr. Hakan Fidan, was also detested by Jerusalem the minute it became clear that Fidan was promoted to the job. The Israeli media, in a rare occurrence, targeted and flaked Mr. Fidan harshly and tended to depict him as someone who has closer ties with Iran than Israel. The Israelis, according to sources who have close eyes on the clandestine services and world, are panicked by a possibility that some of the military and diplomatic secrets that have been shared with Turkey can be passed onto Iran and others.
The diplomatic relations also took a heavy hit between Ankara and Jerusalem, when Turkey withdrew its ambassador from Israel in very early days of the crisis. Since then, with almost no or very little behind the scene communication, Turkey has chosen to shout lauder, and angrier at the Israelis. And this is when the US administration began to draw a line with the Turkish government.
Did the AKP sincerely believe that it could push Washington to take a position against Israel, dump it if necessary and support the Turkish position all the way? It appeared throughout the recent weeks that Ankara indeed believed that, through building its own '9-11' rhetoric to convince the Obama administration.
It can be safely argued then, that whoever is in the charge of reading Washington on the side of the AKP government, read Washington upside down, and picked up the mistaken insights.
The Turkish ambassador to Washington, Mr. Namik Tan, is known with his clear understanding and deep familiarity with the realities of the Washington political theater. It is also confirmed by different sources that the Turkish diplomatic channels did indeed ring the alarm bells continuously in recent weeks to warn Ankara that a stormy weather has been gathering against Turkey in Washington which would be extremely difficult to defy once starts to act.
The next question then becomes which other channels are in the loop, between Ankara and Washington that produce many of the miscalculated analyses, which mostly run against the realities of Washington or the official diplomatic cables, and known that they arrive on policy making desks?
Nowadays, another huge disadvantage of the current Turkish government is its lack of credible and well-connected backchannel relations with Washington's power houses. It was easy to recognize the negative effect of this missing chain just a week ago when the AKP Parliamentary delegation was in Washington. The AKP delegation was consisted of prominent Parliamentary figures in its ranks to explain Turkey's position in Washington highest officials possible. However, the delegation ended up meeting none of the first class American Congressional leaders, and the US administration officials.
For the last few weeks, "no" vote at the United Security Council coincided with the flotilla crisis, and for many, this coincides also validated the arguments that suggest Turkey drifts away from the West. Whether the members of the US Congress know much about the Turkish foreign policy and its newly found regional leadership aspirations, is a different topic. However, various letters have been distributed to the members of the Congress throughout weeks received a record number of signatures. For instance, 87 out of 100 senators did not hesitate to sign on a letter that targeted Turkey's foreign policies, without naming names, next to ask stronger support for Israel from Obama.
Turkey now seems to be put in a dog house in Washington for a while. The US administration treats Turkey extremely carefully, and the statements that came from the various State Department officials in recent days, lack excitement, spirit and warmth. This stonewalling attitude of the US administration does not mean necessarily it wishes to alienate the Turkish administration. However, it does signal that it will not tolerate some of the harsher rhetoric that repeatedly come from there.
Israel eased the blockade on Gaza last week, and Turkey's role to push Israel in that direction is undeniable. The Turkish administration can build on this noteworthy success and be persistent to see the total end of the blockade in foreseeable future. Though, Turkey also must be able to calculate its priorities and preferences when it comes to new engagement and disengagement policies in the region.
Ankara, first, shall start spending more time to read Washington better. The US domestic politics, and the turbulent months ahead will even more complicate the power balance in Washington, most likely resulting a weaker President in few months time along with a stronger legislative branch and the opposition.
Ankara cannot afford to misread Washington any longer.
 
26 Comments   Bookmark and Share  printer friendly PRINTER FRIENDLY

READER COMMENTS

Guest - James
2010-06-30 23:38:35
 These are all Israelis talking here. I think a large part of the American foreign policy establishment in the U.S. would like to see a more assertive democratic, Muslim majority Turkey, with NATO membership in the M.E. Don't discount domestic policy in driving the U.S. At least until November elections the U.S. will be forced to back Israel 100%, not because it is in America's interests, but because AIPAC and its donors help pay for political campaigns, and Israel and its lobby intimidate politicians into supporting Israel. They throw money at candidates that don't sign onto AIPAC letters, and label them terrorist supporters. But Israel is becoming partisan, and democrats, before Obama, were starting to question Israel. If Israel continues with its policies, and is unable to explain them, a shift in American opinions is possible. And AIPAC will be weakened! 
Guest - Alex
2010-06-29 19:16:12
 With regard to perception of Turkey, the strongest lesson from the flotilla incident seems to be that Turkey has no loyalty whatsoever to people who have treated it as friends. Whatever the merits of the Gaza situation, no one will ever trust Turkey again. What sort of country sets a trap for a country with which it has had friendly relations, and then bitterly denounces that country in the most insulting terms? If Turkey can act like that towards Israel, clearly it has no qualms about doing so towards other 'partners' (e.g. NATO or EU) should the perceived needs of the moment dictate. The loss of confidence in Turkey will have long term implications. 
Guest - BENEZRAA
2010-06-28 21:19:42
 THE MAIN THRUST OF THE ARTICLE IS VITALLY IMPORTANT, IN FACT... Has Turkey already jumped off the precipice between it's NATO alliance and it's alliance with Iran? Knowing or believing that Iran is or may soon be nuclear ready, bluff or not, the Turkey-Syria-Iran Axis consolidation is a profound shift of power in the Middle East and in the World. Such an Axis including Hezbollah (Lebanon) and Hamas (Gaza) may well provoke World War Three, a war that may have already set sail or may set sail soon. So-called "Peace Flotillas" that threaten Israel would not be tolerated by the nations that send them. Imagine; suppose Israel were to send such a flotilla to aid the PKK! Hello! The Turkey-Syria-Iran Axis should take a severe look at their own culpabilies in pressing Israel's naval blockade of Gaza, preferably before WW3 breaks out.... 
Guest - dkjack
2010-06-28 19:43:58
 Alas, foreign relations are being driven by domestic politics. If one seeks to win favour amongst the Islamists in his country, what better way than to support an anti-Israel provocation like the flotilla? The ideal of Atatürk -- of making Turkey a full partner in the community of civilized nations -- is being undermined by the Islamists and the demagogues who pander to them. 
Guest - Hublo
2010-06-27 16:42:47
 @ UK Bloke. You write "What about the strong body of evidence that both the US and Israel are funding the PKK? " Can you please show this STRONG BODY of evidence please? And please not, I am asking for what you claim i.e. a "strong body of evidence" not just some vague indications. Until I will not trust what you are writing, and so should no one else. 
Guest - vhardman
2010-06-27 10:39:47
 Apparently sending a flotilla to break an allies blockade is not considered an act of war in Turkey???? Luckily for this flotilla it was not sunk as it could have been and if Lebanese or Iranian ships attempt it they will be 1 Your sense of proportion is sadly lacking and mars the value of your article ? 
Guest - Human
2010-06-27 09:34:30
 UK Bloke. Be so good as to point us to this 'strong body of evidence that both the US and Israel are funding the PKK' will you ? There's a good chap. 
Guest - Uri D.
2010-06-27 07:25:13
 The real question now is, when NATO will reject Turkey, that by all means, under the AKP is anti-west. The Turkish support for the Hamas terror organization, the Hezbollah terror organization, as well as IHH that turn to be terror supporting organization cannot be tolerated anymore. Turkey under the AKP lost any integrity; should it continue that way, kicking off Turkey from NATO is just a question of when, not if. 
Guest - Gary
2010-06-27 03:29:10
 Ironically, because of the Erdogan’s rhetoric, Turkey can’t even take a credit for braking the blocade. The credit deservingly went to the Quartet and Tony Blair while Erdogan continue insisting on the apologies and complete lifting of the blockade. Good luck with that.. 
Guest - Gary
2010-06-27 03:26:04
 Ankara has misread the EU as well. Apart of the few customary statements on the morning of the flotilla disaster the only reaction from the EU was further mistrust of the current Turkish government. The flotilla events just proved the reason behind the reservations that many in Europe had with regard to Turkey joining the EU. 
Guest - andy from DC
2010-06-27 02:39:20
 The author is assuming that Mr Erdogan made a mistake. It is far more likely that He is doing all this knowing what the results will be. In the time since the Gaza Flotilla lost 9 dead attacking the Isreali Commandos thousands of Muslims have been slaughtered in Pakistan and Kyrgyzstan, Did Turkey hold rallies for these innocent victims who, unlike the Turkish dead did not go looking for a fight? Of course not, because they were slaughtered by other Muslims. It happens every day from Sudan to Uzbekistan, yet Erodgan says nothing and cares not. Why? Most people in the USA have drawn their conclusions and they do not include the idea that Turkey is simply making a "mistake". 
Guest - Lion
2010-06-27 00:39:35
 Erdogan went too far with the harsh rhetoric’s, those started several years prior to the flotilla incident, and has only escalated to a crescendo. The intent for some time was to shift some of the axis as it is well called in the comments and discussions at Turkey. I am not sure it is for Turkey's benefit, unless one assumes that the Arab world and Iran are the next leading forces in the world. These steps are viewed as opposing the west and Turkey has lost a lot. Regarding internal and domestics affairs, I don't know, maybe secularism and liberalism is not such a valued issues by the Turks, but this is yet to be learnt. 
Guest - henry laycock
2010-06-26 22:05:35
 It may be of interest to note that Mr Tanir is in the employ of a US corporation, the Allbaugh International Group, which describes itself as offering 'emergency, security, and anti-terrorism planning'. Mr Tamir also studied at George Mason University. Furthermore, that university runs a program on what it calls 'Political Instability' which is openly funded by the CIA. 
Guest - henry laycock
2010-06-26 21:54:34
 It is apparent from a number of the comments, as indeed from the article by Mr. Tanir himself, that the influence of Israeli propaganda, whether overt or covert, remains strong. The suggestion that Turkey must curry favor with Washington, and submit to the power and influence of Israel, while forgetting about the continuing gross injustice done to the Palestinians, is morally disgusting. 
Guest - Honest Abe
2010-06-26 19:08:17
 Turkey showed her true colors. 
Guest - Rich
2010-06-26 15:40:50
 While you seem to have some understanding that Turkey's Prime Minister has risked a lot for his own domestic politics, he has also lit the match of anti-Semitism in Turkey too. Putting that aside, Mr. Erdogan set back "peace" many years. Turkey is not a credible mediator between Israel and the Arab states, and so long as the AKP is in charge, it cannot be trusted by Israel at all. Israel and "peace" will have to wait for Turkey to return to its senses. Even then, this launching by a friendly nation of an armed flotilla against Israel will not be soon forgotten- neither in Israel- nor in Washington nor in Europe. For while the Europeans enjoyed the attack on Israel- they also- do not trust Turkey's intentions. 
Guest - UK Bloke
2010-06-26 14:44:01
 Are you suggesting Ilham that Ankara should should reject it's values in the cause of defending Israel whenever it seeks to kill Turks? What about the strong body of evidence that both the US and Israel are funding the PKK? Your loyalty is suspect my dear friend. Very suspect. 
Guest - ISRAEL LEVIN
2010-06-26 14:34:57
 Basic facts must be understood: 1. Israel is fighting to exist and shall never commit suicide. 2. Iranian port in Gaza endangers Israel existance (Look in the map and get it). 3. Unlike Turkiye US is truely Israel ally. Combine 1, 2 and 3 and you will understand Israel and US positions. 
Guest - Omer, Israel
2010-06-26 10:49:39
 President Ahmadinejad of Iran is percieved as a new kind of Hitler by most Israelis - because of his public plans and declarations to totally destroy Israel, and because he denies the fact of the Holocaust. Most of the Israelis lost family members in the Holocaust. Most of the Turkey-supporting Jewish community in Greece & former Yugoslavia was murdered by the Nazis. Therefore, anyone that helps Ahmadinejads' nuclear program, and everyone that seeks warm security ties with Iran- might be seen as a colaborator of the Iranian-Fascism. I'm sad that PM Erdogan doesn't understand what he's doing and how he offends us Israelis. 
Guest - Hublot
2010-06-26 09:14:33
 The hard rethorics also made the western media taking a closer look at the "activists" and the way they were presented was not only flattering. Also Turkey's relation with IHH was scrutinized, and that wasnt either particularly nice from Turkey's point of view. The third issue was that many Western newspapers also thought that Turkey was overreacting and blow the issue totally out of proportion. So the PR effects for Turkey were certainly not positive over all. This whole affair has only produced losers, and no one has been benefitting. 
Guest - kwell
2010-06-26 06:19:52
 a good summing up. useful insider look. i started to think what exactly Fidan's background... 
Guest - Suleyman
2010-06-26 05:56:41
 Ankara has not 'misread' Washington. Rather they've read them perfectly and decided that continual coddling and acceptance of Israeli crimes can not be tolerated. Washington has to continually make excuses for and support Israel, regardless of what that nation does. The Jewish Lobby and Zionist US Congress will not allow anything else. But Ankara is under no such constraints, we can make policy based on reality and our own interests. Turkey does not seek conflict with Israel or any other nation. But we will not turn a blind eye when Israel flagrantly violates the human rights of Palestinians or Turkish citizens in international waters. Turkish middle east policy must be based on what's good for Turkey, not what's good for Israel. If Mr. Tanir can't understand that than I wonder where his allegiances lay? 
Guest - Emile
2010-06-26 03:00:14
 Dear Mr. Tanir, I read your article. It is excellent and wise. We were all shocked to learn about the flotilla. It was very clear, from the videos of the events, that this was a Turkish provokation. Although things calmed down somewhat, we are also very astonished, that the Turkish engaged all available negative forces, instead of the positive ones to solve this problem. Knowing Turkish history since Ataturk, and the progress Turkey has made towards civilization and approachment to the West, we are more than amazed about the sudden turn the Turkish government has taken, which is neither logic, nor to Turkey's advantage. By getting closer to Iran, to Syria, to the Hamas, and to Hizbollah, how can Turkey expect the American government to respect it? Even more so, we are astonished that Turkey has provoked and attacked its best ally and the Jewish people who have always followed and admired it since the days of the Spanish inquisition. I hope that your article will spread the wisdom. 
Guest - Islandergene
2010-06-26 02:50:18
 How Turkey could have become so culturally and politically lost to get into bed with the Israelis in the first place is what really needs examining. 
Guest - Omer
2010-06-26 01:17:17
 "The flotilla attack, which turned out to be one of the saddest events of the Republic of Turkey's recent history" - yes it was a terrible tragedy, but what about some proportions here. Scan your newspaper in the last 10 years and you can easily find 100 events more tragic than this one. Not to mention the insult (here in the US) comparing it with 9/11 ... sometime I have the feeling that this orchestrated exaggerations have only one objective to incite the public for internal politics purposes and to gain some cheap support in the Arab world... this support will not hold any water ... simple as is ... wait and see... meanwhile we are left with serious problems while the public attention is diverted to some other place ... it will bounce back soon. 
Guest - Kemal
2010-06-26 01:03:03
 Ilhan Bey, 'Ankara's Washington misreading' ... I think you are misreading the consequences of our government continuous provocations ... no one in the west (and some in the east) appreciate that ... on the contrary, the PM rhetoric's reinforce the rejectors of Turkey in the EU ... in fact your second mistake is your observation regarding Turkey's achievement with the Flotilla - wakeup, we are in the Damage Control of this act !!! BTW, each time you indicate these 'achievement' you admit that the government was behind this provocation ... or shall I call it PLOT ... a popular word lately in Turkey

Obama's mixed signals caused troubles for Turkey

   Friday, June 18, 2010
Following a historic "no" vote at the United Nations Security Council, or UNSC, the other week, the relationship between Turkey and the U.S. has been going through a difficult patch. Prior to the vote, through different channels, the U.S. administration officials and various Congressional members reflected their pre-anger mode to the Turkish side, if the Turkish side were to go against the sanctions. Some seasoned foreign policy experts also reflected this anger and stated repeatedly that a 'no' vote at the UNSC against the U.S. might bring serious consequences to bear.
However, the most powerful component of the Washington policy making body, the White House, has chosen to stay quiet, at least publicly, after the Turkish revolt in New York. Both run up to the UNSC vote, and its following hours and days, the U.S. Administration officials cautiously treated the situation and avoided making angry remarks.
The White House senior administration officials summoned the Turkish press members to the White House to explain the U.S. position clearly, right after the UNSC vote. The officials seemed relaxed or even careless while responding to the questions of the Turkish press about what just happened and what others might follow. When I talked to another White House official on the same day that the meeting was conducted, the only thing I heard from this official was that "the White House is frustrated" and does not know what to make of Turkey's stance.
A week after the flotilla crisis and a few days before the UNSC vote on the sanctions package against Iran, I talked to another senior White House official who has been closely involved with matters regarding Turkey day in and out. The Senior official told me that "Turkey's Iran policy should not be over-analyzed." The official went on saying that "Turkey, like the U.S., also does not want Iran to have nuclear weapons... Friends sometimes can disagree." Talking with a senior White House official on the phone, who tells me that Turkey's Iran policy should not be over-emphasized, was pretty shocking.
So, how is it possible that on the one hand the U.S. administration officials have been extremely cautious and calm while commenting on the relations between the U.S. and Turkey, but about every other indication in Washington signals the exact opposite of this "calming" posture?
The answer lies mostly on President Obama and his never understood Middle East policy. Obama has changed his tones radically throughout the sixteen months of his presidency while directing the Arab-Israeli peace process as well as the policy on Iran.
Obama, on the Arab-Israeli front, first tried to push back the right wing Netanyahu government, hoping that it would either compromise or collapse. When the White House saw neither is happening, then it started to backpedal only to run over the Abbas government this time.
Obama's Iran policy also sounds like another backpedaling story. Obama, who just could not decide whether to try for more diplomacy or to work harder to bring heavier sanctions against Iran, intentionally or not, misled the Turkish party.
I asked Mr. Robert Gibbs, the White House Press Secretary, whether there were any mixed signals that came from the White House run up to the UNSC vote that might have misguided Turkey. Mr. Gibbs, instead of giving direct answer on this "mixed signals" question, stated simply that the White House disappointed Turkey's stance at the Council vote.
Apart from sending just too many mixed signals to the outside world, the Obama administration is also in a place that cannot afford to loose a Muslim ally. Obama, and the Democrats, for years, accused the former administration for mishandling the relations with the Muslim world. Now after 8 years of "mistaken" policies, how can the Obama administration elucidate loosing the U.S.' one of the oldest Muslim allies in the world.
Though the president's silence does not necessarily stop leaders and members of the U.S. Congress to whip and threat Turkey. Some of the Congressional leaders already began talking about bringing the Armenian genocide resolution, which passed at the House of Foreign Affairs Committee a couple of months ago, back to the House floor soon. It must be noted that there is no strong break left In Washington these days to prevent such resolution reaching the House floor and put on a vote eventually. The most used argument for Turkey's importance is its "strategic alliance," or "importance" to the U.S. These days nobody in Washington talks about these attributions anymore.
The BP rig explosion in the Gulf of Mexico and oil leak that has been following for two months, which became the biggest environmental catastrophes in American history, has weakened the Obama presidency dramatically. Obama, who once gave the most exhilarating messages of our times through his magical speeches and words, suddenly became another politician with very limited powers, who is even not being able to "plug the hole." And weak standing, also would make it very difficult for Obama to interfere in Congress, particularly if there is a strong consensus on any given matter.
When I talked to another Senior White House official on Thursday and told him that statements that came from the U.S. Congressional members during the week leaves no other choice but to write some terrible scenarios for the relationships between the U.S. and Turkey. The senior official told me that he has nothing to add to this analysis!
While the Turkish delegation was in Washington, the head of TUSIAD, Mrs. Umit Boyner was also in Washington and met with the Secretary of State Hillary Clinton on Thursday late afternoon for about 40 minutes. Following the meeting, Mrs. Boyner gave a press conference and stated that their meeting with Clinton was dominated by the Iran's nuclear program and the Israeli-Turkish problems. The Turkish Parliamentary delegation could not secure an appointment with Mrs. Clinton, instead, grudgingly, they settled for a meeting with Mr. Philip Gordon, Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs.
 
4 Comments   Bookmark and Share  printer friendly PRINTER FRIENDLY

READER COMMENTS

Guest - Charlie- France
2010-06-27 01:02:48
 @andy Maybe Turkey is tired of the blatant double standards the American foreign policy has towards Muslim countries in the Middle East. Israel has hundreds of Nukes, Israel a country that has constantly and consistently invaded other countries since its creation, occupying Palestinian land illegally, with over 60 UN resolutions against them. The United States has absolutely nothing to say to Israel or the western world when it comes to sending weapons inspectors to Israel? What a joke!! Iran has not invaded a country in 2oo years. Don’t you think that the United States has committed enough atrocities against the Iraqi people?1.3 millions Iraqi civilians have been murdered in Iraq since 2003 and a further 5 million Iraqi people displaced. Dont you all think you have done enough?Take a good hard look at yourselves before passing judgement on other countries. The United States and the UK have lost the right to take the moral high ground on such issues,&the world is tired of your lies. 
Guest - ivory
2010-06-20 23:23:27
 useful piece to see the current discourse from the US and how Obama's instable approach hurts allies behavior! 
Guest - andy From DC
2010-06-20 19:17:24
 So your argument is that Turkey stabbed the USA in the back because Obama did not tell them not to ? Wow,that's a new one Mr Erdogan has made his choices, he would rather be a good friend of Iran than the United States. Given where Mr Erdogan wishs to take Turkey this is a rational decision. However it is rather strange to believe that Americans will not notice that Turkey has descended down the Islamist rabbit hole.If you choose to act like a third world Muslim country you can expect to be treated as a third world Muslim country. By the way, where were you planning on getting your next generation of , well, everything. Cause you do not make anything more complex in Turkey than a sandwich. 
Guest - Dinos
2010-06-19 22:41:04
 Ilhan, Sometimes issues are more complex than meet the eye: http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,701109,00.html

Thursday, June 17, 2010

The Israeli-made disaster

The Israeli Navy forces’ deadly flotilla raid shook the world and created broad condemnation of Israel this week. According to the latest account, nine people were killed, dozens injured and hundreds detained, only to be released when Israel was given stern warnings by Turkey.
There are a number of reasons that made the world’s public opinion rapidly build against Israel over this particular incident.
First, the Israeli administrations of recent years have gained, with their various policies on Gaza, the hostility of public opinion across Europe and certainly in the Muslim world, mainly through mass media and the Internet. The Gaza blockade, which has been going on for more than three years since Hamas took control, and Operation Cast Lead, which was conducted in December 2008 and resulted in the killing of more than a thousand Gazans, were only the two biggest building blocks that helped quickly gather the stormy outcry this time over this flotilla raid.
However, late Thursday, maybe for the first time, the Netanyahu government showed signs of realizing the destruction it has done to its own cause as well as Palestinians and decided to review its blockade regime and start softening it. Let us hope there will be a more constructive administration in Jerusalem in the coming weeks and months.
When the deadly confrontation happened, mobilized mainly by Turkey’s active or aggressive diplomacy and loud condemnations, most countries made up their minds quickly and passed judgment to blame Israel. Because nobody has to be a military expert to understand that the ships could have been prevented from going to Gaza by many other ways, without any killing. Prime Minister Netanyahu can claim all he wants that the whole world is against his country, a claim he indeed made during his first public appearance following the clash, when he ended up accusing the whole world of “hypocrisy.” When we simply look at today’s isolated countries, we see that all of them have similarly hostile and enemy-focused worldviews. There should be a lesson just there.
One of the biggest losers in this latest fallout is the U.S. administration. This week marks the first anniversary of the then-historic, nowadays looking mostly theatrical, Cairo speech that was given by U.S. President Barack Obama. In that speech, Obama promised to mend ties with the Muslim world by taking bold steps for the Israeli/Arab conflict.
So, in a quest for a new Middle East policy, but not much of a comprehensive one by Obama’s own account in a Time magazine interview a couple of months ago, the U.S. president put forward a complete settlement freeze as a precondition for the peace process to start and repeatedly displayed tough love for the Netanyahu government. For about a year, Obama exhausted nearly all of his time, political capital and energy in confrontations, mostly public ones, to show he is determined and different.
Once Washington realized that the midterm elections are nearing and big losses in both houses of Congress inevitable, the Obama team decided to make a sharp U-turn to close ranks with Israel’s friends in the U.S. capital and not risk further tension with America’s closest ally in the Middle East. Netanyahu was in the White House only a month ago, where he was met with a cold shoulder, snubbed for an Obama family dinner and received no photo opportunity. Only a little more than one month later, this time through White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel’s invitation, he was getting ready to arrive at the White House to start a honeymoon period, if only he had not botched the flotilla crisis.
The flotilla crisis came right about the time that the White House made a decision to warm relations with the Israeli government and its friends in Washington. Obama does not only need Netanyahu for the reasons above, but he needs Netanyahu to be able to go on with the indirect talks. Otherwise, an administration that has acknowledged the Arab/Israeli peace as a foremost objective on its foreign-policy radar, would end up looking like a complete failure after a year and a half, draining its credibility in the region.
At this particular juncture and critical point for the Obama administration, when viewed from the Middle East, its legacy is about to disappear forever due to not being able to get anything right.
Early this week, on Tuesday, when Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu visited Washington for a day, U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and White House National Security Adviser Jim Jones spent an extraordinary long time meeting with him. Turkey has been the most discussed foreign country in Washington since it helped broker a deal with Iran three weeks ago.
Gen. Jones, however, was hosting also another foreign delegation in the White House on the same day, assembled by Israel’s Washington Ambassador Michael Oren and Netanyahu’s National Security Adviser Uzi Aden. It is hard to speculate how Mr. Jones dealt with two almost-enemy countries on the same day, except the fact that we know the Israeli delegation spent about four hours in the White House without receiving any criticism about their actions during and after the flotilla raid.
For months, many Middle East analysts and Jewish intellectuals have been arguing that if the current Israeli administration keeps on with their policies on the occupation, blockade and settlements, Israel will enter a total isolation zone in which it will earn itself a lot of unwelcoming countries near and far. Following one of the saddest incidents in relations between Turkey and Israel in the Eastern Mediterranean, it is safe to say that Israel has sped up to reach that isolation zone.
When I voiced the opinion about the looming flotilla crisis last week, I predicted that the Israeli leader would have enough international-affairs reading to handle the flotilla crisis and use his scheduled, then postponed, meeting with the U.S. president to spank Turkey, while giving smiley pictures to mark his start of a honeymoon with Obama. I made a mistake. I couldn’t predict his administration would have processed the crisis by choosing the worst-possible careless and incompetent way.
Netanyahu also succeed in making Turkey look like a radical Arab country, stuck with a “with us or against us” mentality. It is still not clear how much Turkey’s public opinion has changed over a week while viewing the world politics, how many hundreds of thousands of youngsters in Turkey decided this past week that the Jewish people and the Americans are their enemies. One would only hope that Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s and Minister Davutoğlu’s repeated fuming statements will not at some point spiral out to coil the emotions of Turkey’s Mediterranean youth to make them hate-mongers while viewing the “others.”
About everything the Israeli government did last week worked against its case, helped to increase radicalism in the Muslim world and was detrimental to regional peace.
If nothing else, Israel helped the Turkish administration make a better case for its regional-power aspirations to steer a more conservative and Muslim nationalist country.
In brief, a great manmade disaster, that Israel created.
 
5 Comments   Bookmark and Share  printer friendly PRINTER FRIENDLY

READER COMMENTS

Guest - Esperalzi Malaysia
2010-06-07 21:53:28
 @Ray Turko: If Erdogan's action takes Turkey back to the 18th century, where to does Israel's action of killing unarmed activists take Israel? To a civilized future? As for the Turkish Generals, I think their good old days of toppling democratically-elected governments are over. This is 2010, military coup d'etats are things of the past, not to mention undemocratic. Funny, for someone who complains Erdogan going backwards to the 18th century, you are pining for a Turkey that goes backwards to the days of military coups.Get real! 
Guest - RAY TURKO
2010-06-07 01:22:52
 Did Turkey lose its sanity? Where is the Turkish secular majority? Where are the Generals who are supposed to uphold the Turkish constitution and guarantee a secular government and State? This entire fiasco is orchestrated by Erdugan who is a fanatic Islamist. Every move, so far, has been carefully planned to follow his plan and take Turkey back to the 18th century. I wonder..Are Turkish intelectuals scratching their heads watching their country regress into what will become a rogue fanatical Muslim state? Does anyone in Turkey remember Ataturk? Did his legacy matter at all? Will no one stand up against Erdugan and bring him back down in size? I wonder who has the courage to answer my questions. 
Guest - kwell
2010-06-05 18:12:29
 Israel botched it severely.. it has to apologize, it made turkey hero.. what a terrible adm. Israel got! 
Guest - Victor
2010-06-05 11:43:21
 Netanyahu is well known in the USA as a liar and scoundrel. How does once a disgraced politician get to be elected PM again? Only in Israel! Anyway, here is a brief history of this hu-man: Binyamin ‘Bibi’ Netanyahu's first stint as Prime Minister came between 6/1996 and 7/1999. According to reports, Bibi showed his political naivety by antagonizing Clinton privately, leading to the now famous outburst by the then white house spokesman Joe Lockhart, who described him as "one of the most obnoxious individuals you're going to come into - just a liar and a cheat. He could open his mouth and you could have no confidence that anything that came out of it was the truth." His premiership in 1999 ended largely in failure, and Barak's job of beating him at the polls was made all the more easy because Netanyahu was mired in corruption and womanizing scandals. He has been married three times. His election as Prime Minister for the second time came in March 2009. He has sunk Israel since then. 
Guest - Mu Abhad
2010-06-05 02:52:59
 This article is just plain silly and utter nonsense!